I have completed my first week at TCASK. It was amazing!
The full-time staff at TCASK bring a great enthusiasm and drive to the office setting. There are three: Rev. Stacy Rector (Executive Director), Isaac Kimes (Community Organizer focused on Students), and Denver Schimming (C.O. focused on Law Enforcement). We had lunch together on my first day and shared our stories. Their hearts are in the right place for this job and their minds are incredible. They will truly step up and be some of my greatest teacher
s this year!
I admit that I accepted the placement at TCASK for the simple fact that it was a controversial, social justice issue that I knew basically nothing about. I knew I was opposed to the death penalty but when I was approach by people with "Why would you want to do that?" or "Do you really believe you should stop the death penalty? Those people are horrible. I say 'burn 'em.'" I didn't know what to say. I didn't have any facts to back up my reasoning. After one week I have some answers.
A Death Penalty Study Committee has been created in the TN Legislature to dissect the capital punishment laws in the state in order to, not abolish, but revise the way in which the system is carried out. This study committee is broken into three subcommittees: promptness (efficency of trial and punishment completion), accuracy ( facts, proof, witness, etc), and fairness (fair trial, racial, mental illness, good lawyer).
On Monday I attended the fairness committee meeting and on Tuesday the full committee met. It was like watching court tv (which I rarely do). High up defense attorneys, district attorneys, senators, and reps sat behind a raised, U-shaped desk, with individual microphones at each seat and a man with a gavel, debating on the issue at hand. Experts testified to the committee. Barry Scheck, from the O.J. Simpson trial, spoke to the committee about the need for DNA evidence in convictions. His 3 1/2 hour lecture also highlighted multiple crimes where wrongful convictions have occured because of a lack of proper evidence storage and DNA collection (all recommendations that TN is not in accordance with). Mr. Scheck is the co-founder of an agency called The Innocence Project. This group works specifically with DNA and has helped to exonerate over 200 people who have been wrongfully convicted of crimes. Innocent people being jailed does happen, the execution of innocent people has happened.
Another thing I learned was the imbalance between the prosectution and defense representation. The prosecution represents the state. Because of this, they have the freedom to decide who will try which case, how much money they will put into each case, and so forth. The defense is appointed by the trial judge. The judge then decides how much money that lawyer can spend on witnesses, experts, proper tests, etc. This is why so often death penalty cases file for misrepresentation or unfair trial. Defense lawyers in capital cases often have heavy case loads already and they are barely given enough money to pay their expenses let alone produce a proper case. The fairness committee proposed creating a defense office that works to recruit good lawyers who have the time to take on the case and manages its own money for each case. This idea would truly level the playing field and create a fair trial. With that said, the state representatives present at the committee meeting were opposed. I don't get it.
The study committee has been granted an extension to meet until Dec. 31, 2008. It will be interesting to see what happens before then.
The full-time staff at TCASK bring a great enthusiasm and drive to the office setting. There are three: Rev. Stacy Rector (Executive Director), Isaac Kimes (Community Organizer focused on Students), and Denver Schimming (C.O. focused on Law Enforcement). We had lunch together on my first day and shared our stories. Their hearts are in the right place for this job and their minds are incredible. They will truly step up and be some of my greatest teacher
I admit that I accepted the placement at TCASK for the simple fact that it was a controversial, social justice issue that I knew basically nothing about. I knew I was opposed to the death penalty but when I was approach by people with "Why would you want to do that?" or "Do you really believe you should stop the death penalty? Those people are horrible. I say 'burn 'em.'" I didn't know what to say. I didn't have any facts to back up my reasoning. After one week I have some answers.
A Death Penalty Study Committee has been created in the TN Legislature to dissect the capital punishment laws in the state in order to, not abolish, but revise the way in which the system is carried out. This study committee is broken into three subcommittees: promptness (efficency of trial and punishment completion), accuracy ( facts, proof, witness, etc), and fairness (fair trial, racial, mental illness, good lawyer).
On Monday I attended the fairness committee meeting and on Tuesday the full committee met. It was like watching court tv (which I rarely do). High up defense attorneys, district attorneys, senators, and reps sat behind a raised, U-shaped desk, with individual microphones at each seat and a man with a gavel, debating on the issue at hand. Experts testified to the committee. Barry Scheck, from the O.J. Simpson trial, spoke to the committee about the need for DNA evidence in convictions. His 3 1/2 hour lecture also highlighted multiple crimes where wrongful convictions have occured because of a lack of proper evidence storage and DNA collection (all recommendations that TN is not in accordance with). Mr. Scheck is the co-founder of an agency called The Innocence Project. This group works specifically with DNA and has helped to exonerate over 200 people who have been wrongfully convicted of crimes. Innocent people being jailed does happen, the execution of innocent people has happened.
Another thing I learned was the imbalance between the prosectution and defense representation. The prosecution represents the state. Because of this, they have the freedom to decide who will try which case, how much money they will put into each case, and so forth. The defense is appointed by the trial judge. The judge then decides how much money that lawyer can spend on witnesses, experts, proper tests, etc. This is why so often death penalty cases file for misrepresentation or unfair trial. Defense lawyers in capital cases often have heavy case loads already and they are barely given enough money to pay their expenses let alone produce a proper case. The fairness committee proposed creating a defense office that works to recruit good lawyers who have the time to take on the case and manages its own money for each case. This idea would truly level the playing field and create a fair trial. With that said, the state representatives present at the committee meeting were opposed. I don't get it.
The study committee has been granted an extension to meet until Dec. 31, 2008. It will be interesting to see what happens before then.


No comments:
Post a Comment