INSANITY VS. SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS
Within the past two weeks the Tennessee Committee to Study the Administration of the Death Penalty has met twice. So much has been covered within a very short time but it is important that things start to develop because the committee’s time is finished on December 31, 2008. The great hope of TCASK was that the study committee, if nothing else, would produce a recommendation to the legislature that would exempt the severely mentally ill from receiving the death sentence. Severe mental illness is something that by the statues of this law would be defined as someone who experiences delusions, hallucinations, and disorganized thought. Also, in order to be exempt from the death sentence the mental illness should have been diagnosed prior to the crime. The general public may believe that insanity is a plea that is used too often in murder cases, that it is just a viable excuse that can’t be proven wrong. Well:
1. An insanity plea an excuse that is presented during the conviction phase of the trial… meaning is this person guilty or innocent? They are guilty by insanity does not mean the person is innocent… it does not mean that that person will walk out and walk the streets because they had once pleaded crazy.
2. A person being exempt from the death penalty because of a severe mental illness is something that is determined at the sentencing phase of the trial. This is the point in time where the judge deliberates the best punishment for the guilty party in the presented crime.
Currently there are two demographics of people who are exempt from the death penalty in Tennessee: juveniles and the mentally retarded. This decision has been made because the court believes that neither of these parties is fully aware of the severity of the crimes that they have committed and therefore they are not culpable. I would argue that the severely mentally ill, those who are so sick that they can’t function in our society could be even less aware of their actions and just as inculpable.
Those who opposed the idea of exempting the mentally ill were able to push the issue to the backburner at the first meeting and at the second meeting they suggested that there be a study of the mentally ill and the death penalty. Though it would have been fantastic to see a recommendation come out of the committee for the legislature to discuss the mental illness issue, a study committee is a decent compromise for both parties. I hope that this issue does actually become a study rather than, like so many, be thrown to the wayside.
PROPOSALS TO THE LEGISLATURE
The rest of the committee’s work in these meetings included recommendations for the legislature to review:
1. The audio or video taping of interrogations.
2. Make a law that allows for open file discovery... so that both sides of the case hold the same evidence and understanding
3. Create an independent authority to oversee capital defense services including recruit, train, monitor, etc. of good defense lawyers
4. Create a realistic timeframe for the post-convictions procedures to take place.
The committee needs to meet at least one more time before the end of the year in order to vote on a proposed document that will act as a summary of the entire year's study and will include their recommendations to the legislature.
12.04.2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


No comments:
Post a Comment